Let's Chat

Quotable Podcast

Scarlett Rosier on 18 Years of Branding, Why Strategy Beats Design, and the Case for Snail Mail


Rhyme and Reason Design Has Been Doing This Since Flash Websites Were a Thing

Scarlett Rosier co-founded Rhyme and Reason Design in 2008 with two business partners. Now it’s her and Karen McKenzie running the show, 18 years later, having survived a recession, a pandemic, and the death of Flash. They’re a woman-owned boutique branding and design agency out of Atlanta that works across three niche markets: tourism and cities, nonprofits (mostly in the Greek sorority and fraternity space), and what they call “cool companies,” which is their catch-all for clients who don’t fit the other two buckets but are open to the more whimsical, fun creative work the team likes to do.

Rosier joined us on the Quotable Media Podcast to talk about how the agency has grown, how she handles clients who think they know better than the designer, and why she still sends snail mail in 2026.

She’s Not the Designer. That’s the Point.

One thing Rosier made clear early on: she can’t draw stick figures. She’s the operations and strategy half of the partnership, not the creative side. And she thinks that’s exactly where most branding conversations should start.

“You need to have the strategy and the smart ideas before you invest in design,” she said. She was literally teaching that point at a marketing college the day before the interview.

When asked the vibe check question of whether she’d take flawless strategy with ugly visuals or stunning visuals with zero strategy, she didn’t hesitate. Strategy every time.

How They Start Every Project

Rosier walked through their process for new clients. Every engagement starts with research and immersion. For clients with the budget and timeline, that means focus groups, surveys, and one-on-one interviews. Big branding projects can take 12 to 14 months start to finish.

For clients who don’t have that kind of time or money, they still run a discovery session and a creative questionnaire. The questionnaire covers project objectives, goals, and target markets, but the questions that really get people going are things like: if your brand were a celebrity, who would it be and why? That one gets to personality fast, and it also tells the team a lot about how the client thinks.

They also send a separate client questionnaire about how people like to communicate, what time of day works best, and personal fun facts. The goal is to understand the whole person, not just the project.

When the Client Has a Terrible Idea, Show It to Them

“Oftentimes when we do what they’ve asked for, they see it and they realize that it’s terrible,” she said. “Which works out really nicely, because you’re like, well, we tried what you said and now you will trust us.”

She said a lot of clients come to them specifically because they felt like a previous agency didn’t listen. So Rhyme and Reason makes a point of hearing them out, executing their vision when asked, and then letting the work speak for itself. Most of the time, the client walks it back on their own.

The Pros and Cons of Niching Down

Rosier had a really practical take on specialization. She compared working in a niche to shooting fish in a barrel instead of an ocean. There are fewer competitors, referrals flow more naturally, and you build expertise fast. Most of their clients in the niche spaces came through referrals.

The downside? Niche markets are vulnerable to things you can’t control. Their tourism clients get a lot of their funding from hotel tax. When nobody’s traveling, whether it’s a pandemic or high gas prices or geopolitical uncertainty, that tax revenue drops and marketing budgets get cut. Same thing happens with nonprofits and Greek organizations when people stop giving.

That’s why the “cool companies” bucket turned out to be critical. It helped them survive the pandemic and has evened out the playing field as the other niches fluctuate. Rosier’s advice: have your niche, but make sure you have something else to lean on when the market shifts, because it will.

Don’t Spend Your Money Here (and Other Things Your Agency Won’t Tell You)

“If you don’t have a strategy, don’t spend your money,” she said. She also told the guys she’s happy to tell clients they don’t need a full custom website when a landing page would do the job. She’d rather educate someone on what to look for in a vendor than take money for work they don’t need.

That attitude, she said, is part of why clients stick around. One of their first tourism clients, Georgetown, Texas, has been with them for 16 years. Another client started with them in the Greek space, moved to a chamber of commerce, and now runs marketing for a bank. He’s been with them the whole time.

An “Overnight Success” 18 Years in the Making

When asked about the agency’s growth, Rosier laughed. “I joked with our business partner a couple years ago. I was like, we’re an overnight success. It’s not an overnight.”

She and Karen are not risk takers. They play it safe. Their priority has always been protecting the team: health insurance, dental, vision, 401k, PTO. The goal was never to chase a big profit margin or rapid growth. It was to build a business where everyone felt secure and the work stayed good.

They established values early and stuck to them. Rosier said that’s made hiring, firing, client selection, and vendor relationships way easier over the years. While other small agencies shuttered during the pandemic or folded when AI started making noise, Rhyme and Reason stayed open by being intentional about the human side of the business.

“People do want to see that there’s someone on the other side that you can have a relationship with,” she said. “Even more so now than ever with AI.”

AI and Canva: Threat or Opportunity?

Rosier doesn’t see AI or Canva as threats. She sees them as tools that level the playing field for clients with tight budgets. Research and data analysis that used to be expensive and time-consuming can now get done faster through tools like ChatGPT and Claude. Design platforms like Canva mean clients can handle day-to-day creative without needing an agency on retainer.

Rather than fighting it, Rhyme and Reason builds templates and hands them off so clients can run with them independently. Rosier thinks that willingness to set clients up for success without the agency actually makes them a better partner, not a less valuable one.


🎙️ About Quotable Media
Quotable Media is a podcast production and media company that helps brands and entrepreneurs tell their stories through professional podcast interviews, video production, and social media content. From full episode production to short-form clips and promotional assets, Quotable turns conversations into content that drives reach and engagement.

🔗 Learn more about Rhyme and Reason Design: rhymeandreasondesign.com

Share this story